| Year of election | Name |
|---|---|
| 1904 | Arthur S Roe |
| 1905 | Norman Leslie |
| 1908 | Stanley Castlehow |
| 1909 | Leonard G Brown |
| 1911 | Harold K Denham |
| 1914 | Allan W L Row |
| 1915 | John N Radcliffe |
| 1918 | Frederick W Paterson |
| 1919 | Victor Grenning |
| 1922 | Tom Lawton |
| 1927 | Franz Konrad Saddler Hirschfeld |
| 1928 | John H Lavery |
| 1930 | Cecil E Kerr |
| 1939 | James K Newman |
| 1958 | Thomas Baxter |
| 1960 | Clive P Hildebrand |
| 1967 | John M Fenwick |
| 1978 | Peter J Wetherall |
| 1981 | Donald Markwell |
| 1982 | David M Rose |
| 1991 | Craig Arnott |
| 1992 | Daniel V Botsman |
| 2006 | Nicholas I Luke |
| 2007 | Ryan A Goss |
| 2019 | Nicholas Salmon |
| 2024 | Jeremy Hunt |
Six Old Boy Rhodes Scholars served in the First World War: A S Roe, L G Brown (1909), H K Denham (1911), A W L Row (1914), J N Radcliffe (1915) and F W Paterson (1918). Donald Markwell was later Warden of Rhodes House, 2009 to 2012. Franz Konrad Saddler Hirschfeld's great-grandson, Ryan Goss, was elected in 2007.